of West Virginia appeared to have scuttled the Democrats’ federal takeover of state voting laws, styled S.1, from which he is the only Democratic dissenter. He objected to its ban on voter-ID requirements. But he is offering a compromise that would impose such requirements on all states. It isn’t much better than the original.
The Manchin measure has the support of Democrats and activists, including failed Georgia gubernatorial candidate
She told CNN last week that the notion progressives oppose voter ID is “one of the fallacies of Republican talking points” and claimed: “No one has ever objected to having to prove who you are to vote.” Never mind that she has denounced bills to expand voter ID as “a redux of Jim Crow in a suit and tie.”
The difference is that Mr. Manchin’s bill wouldn’t require photo ID. Anyone would be permitted to vote by showing a utility bill, a form of ID that only 15 states (including West Virginia) accept. Anyone with a color printer can forge a utility bill. In 2012
son of then-
Rep. Jim Moran
of Virginia, was forced to resign as his father’s field director after the filmmaker
caught him on videotape saying: “They can fake a utility bill with ease.” (Patrick Moran told Politico he thought Mr. O’Keefe was “joking” and quit to avoid becoming a “distraction.”)
A study by economist
finds that 46 of 47 European countries require government-issued photo ID to vote. The exception is Great Britain (although not Northern Ireland): Last month Prime Minister
government said it would make photo IDs mandatory in response to a 2016 Royal Commission report. As the BBC summarized it, “authorities are turning a blind eye to electoral corruption in the UK because of a desire for political correctness.”
The Manchin compromise would mandate permissive policies on absentee and mail-in ballots, which are also stricter in Europe. Mr. Lott found 74% of European countries ban absentee ballots except for citizens living abroad. Another 6% limit them to voters in the hospital or the military, and they require third-party verification and photo ID.
The U.K., which allows postal voting, has had many notable mail-in ballot fraud cases. In
Hungary, which has the loosest mail-in voting in Europe and doesn’t require photo IDs to obtain those ballots, the ruling party won 96% of overseas mail-in votes in 2018. The liberal group Open Democracy notes that fraud is possible because “there is little scope for verification of identities, or to check that people are still alive.”
Eight European countries with strict voting rules allow proxy voting, under which someone can vote on another’s behalf. France and the Netherlands allow proxy voting, but they require that voters notarize the forms.
The new Georgia voting law that Ms. Abrams calls “racist” is much less restrictive than Europe in this regard. Anyone who wants an absentee ballot can obtain one. You don’t need an excuse—only an ID.
Mr. Fund is co-author with
Hans von Spakovsky
of “Our Broken Elections: How The Left Changed the Way You Vote,” forthcoming in the fall.
Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8